Bona Fide Error Defense

Bona Fide Error Defense

Bona Fide Error Defense

The defense requires that the violation was unintentional, resulted from a bona fide error, and occurred despite procedures reasonably adapted to avoid the error. Jerman held it does not cover mistakes of law.

Documented procedures are required.

Alternative Names:

Bona Fide Error|FDCPA Error Defense

Why it Matters?

Jerman's exclusion of legal errors substantially narrowed the defense, since a collector's mistaken interpretation of the statute does not qualify regardless of good faith, leaving the defense available principally for clerical and processing errors. Documented procedures reasonably adapted to prevent the specific error are required, and general quality control programs without a procedure addressing the error at issue do not satisfy the element.

Frequently Confused with

Related terms

Frequently asked questions

What did Jerman exclude?

What did Jerman exclude?

Mistakes of law, so a collector's mistaken statutory interpretation does not qualify regardless of good faith.

What procedures satisfy the element?

What procedures satisfy the element?

Documented procedures reasonably adapted to prevent the specific error, not general quality control programs.