Borrowed Servant Doctrine

Borrowed Servant Doctrine

Borrowed Servant Doctrine

The doctrine imputes an employee's negligence to a borrowing party who assumed control over the work performed. In healthcare it may shift hospital employee negligence to a supervising physician.

Control over the specific work is the test.

Alternative Names:

Borrowed Employee, Loaned Servant Doctrine

Why it Matters?

Control over the specific act rather than general presence is what the doctrine requires, so a surgeon directing a nurse's particular action may borrow that servant while general supervision does not transfer responsibility. Hospitals invoke it to shift liability to physicians and physicians resist for the same reason, which makes it a source of conflict between defendants who otherwise share interests.

Frequently Confused with

Related terms

Frequently asked questions

What does the doctrine require?

What does the doctrine require?

Control over the specific work performed, since general supervision or presence does not transfer employment responsibility.

Why does it create defendant conflict?

Why does it create defendant conflict?

Because hospitals invoke it to shift liability to physicians and physicians resist, dividing defendants who otherwise share interests.