Declarant Unavailability

Declarant Unavailability

Declarant Unavailability

Rule 804(a) defines unavailability to include privilege, refusal to testify, lack of memory, death or infirmity, and absence despite reasonable means to procure attendance. A party cannot create unavailability through wrongdoing.

Procurement efforts must be reasonable.

Alternative Names:

Unavailability|Rule 804(a)

Why it Matters?

Absence beyond subpoena range is not automatically unavailability, since the proponent must show reasonable means were used to procure attendance including a deposition where practicable. That requirement defeats claims of unavailability where the witness could have been deposed. Forfeiture by wrongdoing removes the requirement entirely where a party procured the declarant's absence.

Frequently asked questions

Is distance alone sufficient?

Is distance alone sufficient?

No. The proponent must show reasonable means were used to procure attendance, including deposition where practicable.

What is forfeiture by wrongdoing?

What is forfeiture by wrongdoing?

A rule removing the requirement where a party procured the declarant's absence to prevent testimony.