Extracontractual Damages

Extracontractual Damages

Extracontractual Damages

Extracontractual damages exceed what the policy promised and may include the excess judgment, consequential economic losses, emotional distress, attorney's fees, and punitive damages.

Availability depends on whether the jurisdiction treats bad faith as a tort or confines it to contract remedies.

Alternative Names:

Extra-Contractual Damages, Bad Faith Damages

Why it Matters?

These damages are why bad faith exposure is categorically different from a coverage dispute: a carrier contesting a one hundred thousand dollar claim can face a verdict many multiples larger. That asymmetry is what makes documented reasonable investigation and timely demand responses worth their cost, and it is why the claim file receives such attention in coverage litigation.

Frequently asked questions

What damages are available for bad faith?

What damages are available for bad faith?

Depending on the jurisdiction, the excess judgment, consequential losses, emotional distress, attorney's fees, and punitive damages beyond the policy limits.

Do all states permit extracontractual recovery?

Do all states permit extracontractual recovery?

No. Some confine remedies to contract damages plus interest, while others recognize bad faith as a tort with full extracontractual exposure.