Government Contractor Defense

Government Contractor Defense

Government Contractor Defense

Under Boyle, a contractor is immune where the government approved reasonably precise specifications, the equipment conformed to them, and the contractor warned of dangers known to it but not to the government.

The elements are conjunctive.

Alternative Names:

Boyle Defense, Military Contractor Defense

Why it Matters?

The warning element is where the defense most often fails, since it requires establishing what the contractor knew relative to the government's own extensive knowledge, and internal documents showing undisclosed hazard awareness defeat it. Federal officer removal accompanies the defense and provides a route to federal court that is independently valuable. The defense extends beyond military procurement in some applications.

Frequently asked questions

Which element fails most often?

Which element fails most often?

The warning element, since internal documents showing hazard knowledge the contractor did not disclose to the government defeat it.

What procedural advantage accompanies it?

What procedural advantage accompanies it?

Federal officer removal, which provides a route to federal court independently valuable in state court litigation.