Government Specification Defense

Government Specification Defense

Government Specification Defense

Under the government contractor defense, a supplier is immune where the government approved reasonably precise specifications, the equipment conformed to them, and the supplier warned the government of dangers known to it but not to the government.

It derives from Boyle v. United Technologies.

Alternative Names:

Military Specification Defense, Boyle Defense

Why it Matters?

The defense appears frequently in asbestos litigation involving naval and military equipment, where the government specified insulation materials and controlled the warnings permitted. Its elements are conjunctive, so failing any one defeats it, and the warning element requires establishing what the supplier knew relative to the government's own extensive knowledge. Federal officer removal frequently accompanies the defense.

Frequently Confused with

Related terms

Frequently asked questions

What are the elements?

What are the elements?

Government approval of reasonably precise specifications, conformity to them, and warning the government of dangers known to the supplier but not the government.

Does it support removal?

Does it support removal?

Yes. Federal officer removal is available where the defense is asserted, which is a common route to federal court in military asbestos cases.