Liability Assessment

Liability Assessment

Liability Assessment

Liability assessment analyzes whether the plaintiff can prove each element of the claim and how a jury is likely to allocate fault. It accounts for comparative fault, nonparty responsibility, and any immunities or statutory bars.

The output is typically a percentage likelihood of an adverse liability finding and an expected fault allocation.

Alternative Names:

Liability Analysis, Fault Assessment

Why it Matters?

Expressing liability as a percentage rather than a narrative is what makes it usable for valuation, since exposure is the product of liability probability and damages range. It also forces discipline: counsel who describe liability as defensible without quantifying it leave the carrier unable to set reserves or authority. In comparative fault states, the assessment must address the threshold that bars recovery entirely.

Frequently asked questions

Why express liability as a percentage?

Why express liability as a percentage?

Because exposure calculations require it. A qualitative description cannot be combined with a damages range to produce a valuation or support a reserve.

What most often changes a liability assessment?

What most often changes a liability assessment?

Deposition testimony that contradicts documentary evidence, expert reports on causation, and discovery revealing prior notice of the hazard.