Patient Dumping Claim

Patient Dumping Claim

Patient Dumping Claim

Patient dumping claims arise under EMTALA where a hospital failed to provide an appropriate medical screening examination, failed to stabilize an emergency condition, or transferred an unstabilized patient without satisfying the statutory transfer requirements.

The statute creates a private right of action for personal harm.

Alternative Names:

EMTALA Claim, Anti-Dumping Claim

Why it Matters?

The disparate screening theory is the productive defense focus, because EMTALA requires uniform application of the hospital's own screening protocol rather than competent screening. A hospital that applied its standard protocol has satisfied the statute even if the screening was negligent, which channels the claim to state malpractice law with its procedural prerequisites and caps. Establishing what the protocol required and that it was followed is the analysis.

Frequently Confused with

Related terms

Frequently asked questions

What is the disparate screening theory?

What is the disparate screening theory?

That the hospital applied its screening protocol differently to this patient, which is the EMTALA violation rather than negligent screening.

Does negligent screening violate EMTALA?

Does negligent screening violate EMTALA?

Not by itself. Uniform application of the hospital's own protocol satisfies the statute even where the screening fell below the standard of care.