Prima Facie

Prima Facie

Prima Facie

Prima facie means at first appearance. A prima facie case is evidence sufficient on each element to permit a reasonable factfinder to find for the plaintiff, avoiding judgment as a matter of law.

Establishing a prima facie case shifts the burden of production to the opposing party.

Alternative Names:

At First Sight, On Its Face

Why it Matters?

The concept structures burden-shifting frameworks throughout litigation, most visibly in employment discrimination under McDonnell Douglas, where establishing a prima facie case shifts the burden to the employer to articulate a legitimate reason. Understanding what the prima facie showing requires for each claim tells defense counsel exactly what to attack at summary judgment, since failure on any single element ends the claim.

Frequently Confused with

Related terms

Frequently asked questions

What does establishing a prima facie case accomplish?

What does establishing a prima facie case accomplish?

It permits the claim to survive judgment as a matter of law and shifts the burden of production to the opposing party.

Is a prima facie case enough to win?

Is a prima facie case enough to win?

No. It permits the claim to proceed, but the plaintiff must still carry the ultimate burden of persuasion at trial.