Settlement Class

Settlement Class

Settlement Class

A settlement class is certified in connection with a proposed resolution. Under Amchem, all Rule 23 requirements apply except trial manageability, since the class will not be tried.

Approval requires preliminary approval, notice, a fairness hearing, and a finding that the settlement is fair, reasonable, and adequate.

Alternative Names:

Settlement-Only Class, Rule 23(e) Class

Why it Matters?

Settlement classes let defendants achieve global peace including claims that could not be certified for trial, which is their principal value. The tradeoff is that courts apply heightened scrutiny precisely because there is no adversarial testing of the class definition, and Amchem and Ortiz demonstrate that intra-class conflicts, particularly between present and future claimants, can defeat approval entirely.

Frequently Confused with

Related terms

Frequently asked questions

Do all Rule 23 requirements apply to a settlement class?

Do all Rule 23 requirements apply to a settlement class?

All except trial manageability, since the case will not be tried. Courts apply heightened scrutiny to the remaining requirements because of the absence of adversarial testing.

What defeats settlement class approval?

What defeats settlement class approval?

Intra-class conflicts, particularly between present and future claimants, inadequate representation, and settlements providing disproportionate benefit to counsel relative to the class.