Intervening Cause

Intervening Cause

Intervening Cause

An intervening cause occurs between the defendant's act and the injury. It becomes superseding only if unforeseeable enough to break the causal chain; otherwise the original actor remains liable.

Most intervening causes do not supersede.

Alternative Names:

Intervening Act, Intervening Event

Why it Matters?

The distinction from superseding cause is that intervention alone changes nothing, since a foreseeable intervening act leaves the original defendant fully liable. Counsel sometimes argue intervention as though it were a defense in itself, which invites the response that foreseeability governs. Establishing that the intervening act was outside the range of foreseeable consequences is the argument that matters.

Frequently asked questions

Does an intervening cause relieve liability?

Does an intervening cause relieve liability?

Only if it is superseding, meaning unforeseeable enough to break the causal chain. Foreseeable intervening acts do not.

What is the productive framing?

What is the productive framing?

That the intervening act fell outside the range of consequences a reasonable person would have anticipated.