Litigation Guidelines

Litigation Guidelines

Litigation Guidelines

Litigation guidelines set the operating rules for panel and appointed defense counsel. They typically require early case evaluation and budgets, prior approval for depositions, experts, motions, and travel, prescribed reporting intervals, and staffing restrictions.

They function alongside separate billing guidelines that govern rates, task coding, and invoice format.

Alternative Names:

Defense Counsel Guidelines

Why it Matters?

Guidelines directly shape defense strategy, and the tension they create is real: counsel owes professional duties to the insured, not to the carrier paying the bill. Where a guideline would require counsel to forgo work the insured's defense genuinely requires, most authorities hold the ethical obligation to the client controls and the restriction must be challenged rather than silently followed.

Frequently asked questions

What if litigation guidelines conflict with the insured's defense needs?

What if litigation guidelines conflict with the insured's defense needs?

Counsel's duty runs to the insured. Ethics authorities consistently hold that guideline restrictions cannot override independent professional judgment, and counsel should raise the conflict with the carrier and document it.

Do guidelines apply when the insured is defending within a self-insured retention?

Do guidelines apply when the insured is defending within a self-insured retention?

Often not, or only partially. Within an SIR the insured typically controls the defense and counsel selection, though reporting obligations frequently still apply.