Nuisance (Property)

Nuisance (Property)

Nuisance (Property)

The claim requires substantial interference that a reasonable person would find objectionable and that is unreasonable weighing the utility of the conduct against the harm. Noise, odor, vibration, light, and drainage are common subjects.

Public nuisance affects rights common to the community.

Alternative Names:

Private Nuisance, Property Nuisance

Why it Matters?

The unreasonableness balancing considers the character of the locality, which means industrial activity in an industrial area is judged differently than the same activity beside residences. Coming to the nuisance is not a complete defense but weighs in the analysis where a plaintiff bought next to an established operation. Regulatory compliance also does not immunize, since permitted activity may still unreasonably interfere.

Frequently asked questions

Does regulatory compliance defeat a nuisance claim?

Does regulatory compliance defeat a nuisance claim?

No. Permitted activity may still unreasonably interfere with neighboring use, though compliance weighs in the reasonableness analysis.

Is coming to the nuisance a defense?

Is coming to the nuisance a defense?

Not complete, though it weighs in the balancing where the plaintiff acquired property next to an established operation.