What changes if the fee is flat or contingent?
A flat or contingent fee remains subject to the reasonableness factors in Rule 1.5(a), even though it is not calculated from hours expended. The hourly rule does not become a universal formula for every fee arrangement.
For a flat-fee arrangement, Opinion 512 makes a specific point: if AI enables the lawyer to complete tasks much more quickly, charging the same flat fee as without the tool may be unreasonable. The opinion also states: "A fee charged for which little or no work was performed is an unreasonable fee".
The opinion says the unchanged fee may be unreasonable; that calls for examining the fee under Rule 1.5(a), rather than assuming either that the original agreement settles every question or that faster drafting automatically dictates a particular reduction.
A plaintiff firm working under a contingency fee still has to assess reasonableness, as does a defense firm using a flat fee, and neither assessment can be replaced by multiplying imagined hours saved by an hourly rate. Our reading of the cited discussion is not an automatic percentage reduction whenever AI helps with a task. It is a continuing reasonableness inquiry.
Return to the work performed. In a hypothetical matter, a quickly generated pleading may still require the lawyer to check the underlying records and review the draft for completeness. Those are actual tasks. They belong in the assessment of the work, without inventing hours that would have been spent under a different method.
What should I tell the client before charging for AI?
Opinion 512 says the lawyer must explain the basis for an AI charge before making it, preferably in writing. Saying that the firm uses AI does not, by itself, explain what the client will pay for.
Rule 1.5(b) requires communication of the basis for fees and expenses before or within a reasonable time of commencing representation, preferably in writing, unless the client is regularly represented and the terms are not changing. Opinion 512 then applies that obligation to charging for AI tools or services: explain the basis before making the charge.
Be specific about the distinction. The explanation should make clear whether the charge concerns the lawyer's actual time or an expense for using the tool. Where a firm-wide subscription would otherwise be overhead, the client's agreement to different treatment matters. Where the charge is an actual client-specific expense, identify that basis rather than describing a hypothetical value for time saved.
For billing-guidelines compliance, read the client's or carrier's requirements alongside the fee agreement before deciding what to charge, because a general discussion of permissible AI expenses cannot resolve the terms governing a particular representation. This applies to hourly defense matters and to plaintiff engagements with their own agreed billing terms.
Our glossary entry on billing for AI-assisted work keeps the same distinction between professional time and expenses. When evaluating a tool, the review question also belongs alongside the considerations in 10 questions to ask before choosing a litigation AI platform: what source material will the lawyer need to check? For the bill, record the work actually performed and use the charging basis explained to the client.