What should an ESI protocol settle at the Rule 26(f) conference?
The protocol should turn the parties' discovery proposals into specific terms for preservation and production, with unresolved points identified. Start with the records.
In a hypothetical construction dispute, consider the superintendent's daily report. The discussion might address who kept it and the period it covers, then move to the form in which the other party will receive it. Calling everything project documents leaves those questions unanswered. The same exercise applies to electronically stored information held by either side.
The Federal Rules of Civil Procedure apply in federal court, local rules and standing orders often add more, and state practice differs. This is a general planning guide, not advice on a particular protocol.
Under Rule 26(f)(3)(C), the written discovery plan must state the parties' views and proposals concerning ESI disclosure, discovery or preservation, including the form or forms of production. We would organize the Rule 26(f) conference discussion around these decisions:
Preservation: Identify the information in scope and the reasonable steps proposed to preserve it. Put disagreements about exclusions in writing.
Sources and custodians: Connect proposed custodians to the issues they know about. Address non-custodial sources separately, rather than assuming a list of people covers the file.
Production: Specify the form of production, including any native-file exceptions. Address searchable text and metadata expressly.
Privilege: Discuss the nature and scope of the privilege log, including whether alternatives to document-by-document entries fit the matter.
A format needs more than a label. If the proposed term is searchable PDF, the discussion should still identify what accompanying text and metadata are contemplated and which files require different treatment. Rule 34(b)(2)(E) supplies the federal production framework; Delaware's more specific image-production default is a local example, discussed below.
There is also a route into the scheduling order. Rule 16 permits provisions concerning ESI disclosure, discovery or preservation and agreements under Evidence Rule 502. For the privilege discussion, see Privilege logs under the amended federal rules: what Rules 26(f) and 16(b) now ask.





