What counts as a changed expert report?
A change can sit in a supplement, an amended report or an errata sheet. It can also arrive through deposition testimony, which Rule 26(e)(2) reaches, or a rebuttal that introduces affirmative opinions.
The cover tells you little.
For the Rule 26(a)(2) disclosure, start with what had to be disclosed. Unless otherwise stipulated or ordered, Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(a)(2)(B) requires reporting experts, including retained experts, to provide a report “prepared and signed by the witness”, containing “a complete statement of all opinions the witness will express and the basis and reasons for them” and “the facts or data considered by the witness in forming them”. Supporting exhibits, qualifications, prior testimony and compensation information also belong there.
Non-reporting experts disclose the subject matter and a summary of facts and opinions under Rule 26(a)(2)(C).
The roof opinion illustrates the distinction: unchanged words, expanded repairs. Testimony can narrow an assumption just as quietly; our guide to checking a deposition summary addresses that review.
Which parts of a revised report should you compare first?
Start underneath the conclusion: the reasons for the opinion, the facts or data considered, and the supporting exhibits. Then ask who supplied each assumption.
Read for movement:
A document added to or removed from the materials-considered list.
A different measurement, date or damages period.
A qualifier strengthened or softened.
An opinion relocated to another section.
A changed calculation input, even where the result stays the same.
Keep the qualifiers. “Consistent with” is not “caused by”; a study reporting increased risk does not become a causation finding because a summary needs shortening.
This is not confined to construction. In the Federal Judicial Center's 1998 survey of federal judges, published in 2000, tort cases accounted for 45% of reported trials involving expert testimony, compared with 26% of all civil trials. Historical figures, not today's docket.





