What should successor counsel receive when inheriting a matter mid-case?
Successor counsel should receive the papers and property the client is entitled to, with particular attention to what an unfinished matter requires. Start with an inventory. A folder labeled complete is still something to check against the actual contents.
On the successor-counsel facts addressed in ABA Formal Opinion 471, dated July 1, 2015, the minimum materials to surrender included:
Materials supplied by the client; legal documents filed with a tribunal or completed and ready for filing.
Executed instruments; tribunal orders and other tribunal records.
Correspondence sent or received during the representation, including retained email.
Discovery and evidentiary materials, including interrogatories and answers, deposition transcripts, expert reports, witness statements and exhibits.
Legal opinions issued at the client's request; assessments by third parties that the client paid for.
The Model Rules are a model: the law of the jurisdiction controls, including whether it follows an "entire file" or "end product" approach, and court orders on substitution of counsel are local.
For the incoming team, we suggest making the inventory specific enough to use. Record whether the deposition transcript arrived with its exhibits. Identify an expert report by its author and date rather than accepting a folder named experts as confirmation. Keep a missing-document request separate from a question about what a document means.
Electronic records count as papers. Opinion 471 does not itself settle who pays for format conversion. Nor do the Model Rules define the papers and property to which a client is entitled or directly address how long files must be preserved after a representation closes.





