Bifurcated Punitive Phase

Bifurcated Punitive Phase

Bifurcated Punitive Phase

Bifurcation defers evidence of the defendant's financial condition and sometimes the punitive entitlement question until a separate phase. Several states require bifurcation on request.

The same jury typically hears both phases.

Alternative Names:

Punitive Phase, Two-Phase Punitive Trial

Why it Matters?

Deferring financial condition evidence is the principal benefit, since wealth evidence presented during the liability phase influences the compensatory award as well. Where bifurcation is available on request rather than discretionary, invoking it is nearly automatic for a corporate defendant. Some statutes bifurcate entitlement as well as amount, which prevents the jury from hearing punitive-only evidence while deciding liability.

Frequently asked questions

What does bifurcation defer?

What does bifurcation defer?

Financial condition evidence and in some states the punitive entitlement question, keeping both from the liability phase.

Is bifurcation available on request?

Is bifurcation available on request?

In several states yes as of right, while others treat it as discretionary under general bifurcation authority.