A counteroffer proposes terms differing from those offered, which under contract principles operates as a rejection of the original offer and terminates the offeree's power to accept it.

The original offer cannot be accepted afterward absent renewal.

Alternative Names:

Counter-Demand, Counterproposal

Why it Matters?

The rejection effect matters where a time-limited demand is involved, since responding with a counteroffer extinguishes the ability to accept the original terms and can eliminate the protection accepting would have provided against an excess judgment. Requesting an extension or clarification rather than countering preserves the option. Carriers evaluating policy limits demands should understand that a counteroffer forecloses acceptance.

Frequently asked questions

Does a counteroffer reject the original offer?

Does a counteroffer reject the original offer?

Yes under ordinary contract principles, which terminates the power to accept the original terms absent renewal.

Why does this matter for policy limits demands?

Why does this matter for policy limits demands?

Because countering forecloses acceptance and can eliminate the protection against excess exposure that acceptance would have provided.