High-Low Agreement

High-Low Agreement

High-Low Agreement

A high-low agreement fixes a floor the plaintiff receives even on a defense verdict and a ceiling the defendant pays even on a large plaintiff verdict. Verdicts within the range are paid as rendered.

The agreement is usually confidential from the jury and may be reached before trial, during trial, or while a verdict is pending.

Alternative Names:

High-Low, Floor and Ceiling Agreement

Why it Matters?

High-lows are the practical tool for cases with genuine liability risk and dangerous damages exposure, particularly in venues with nuclear verdict potential. They convert an unbounded outcome into a defined range, which can make trying a case rational when the alternative was overpaying to avoid tail risk. They also require careful coordination with excess carriers, since the ceiling determines whether the excess layer is exposed.

Frequently asked questions

Does the jury learn about a high-low agreement?

Does the jury learn about a high-low agreement?

Typically not. The agreement is usually kept from the jury, though courts may require disclosure to the court and sometimes to non-settling parties.

When is a high-low most useful?

When is a high-low most useful?

When liability is genuinely contested but damages exposure is severe, so both sides gain more from capping the tails than from litigating to an unbounded verdict.